Chapter 5 - NATALIE'S VOICE
The key opened a deposit box at a small church in Marietta.
Natalie had volunteered there during the final months of her relationship with Mason.
The pastor remembered her.
“She seemed frightened near the end,” Reverend Cole told Detective Bell. “She asked whether she could leave something here temporarily.”
Nobody had opened the locked compartment in eight years.
Inside was a digital recorder.
There were also copies of bank statements, photographs, and a letter addressed to Hannah.
The recorder still worked.
Detective Bell warned me that I did not have to listen.
I insisted.
Natalie’s voice filled the hospital room.
She sounded young.
Calm.
Determined.
“If anyone hears this, my name is Natalie Pierce. Mason Whitmore and Beatrice Whitmore have been using my identity to borrow money without my permission.”
I closed my eyes.
Eight years separated us.
Yet her story sounded like mine.
The next recording captured an argument.
Mason accused Natalie of betrayal.
She accused him of fraud.
Then Beatrice entered.
Her voice was unmistakable.
“You think leaving fixes this?”
Natalie answered, “I’m going to the police.”
Mason said, “You’ll destroy everything.”
“You destroyed it yourself.”
Then Beatrice said something that silenced everyone in the hospital room.
“We protected you, Mason. We gave you a life. Don’t let some woman take it away.”
Natalie replied, “You stole his life from his real mother.”
There was a crash.
Then the recording ended.
A second file had been recorded later.
Natalie was crying.
“I’m leaving tonight. If Mason finds this, I don’t know what he’ll do.”
Then she revealed something unexpected.
Richard had offered to help her escape.
I opened my eyes.
“Richard?”
Bell replayed the section.
Natalie clearly said Richard’s name.
According to her recording, Richard promised to drive her to a motel where Hannah could collect her.
But Natalie never arrived.
When confronted again, Richard finally confessed.
He had picked Natalie up.
They drove toward the interstate.
Then Beatrice called him.
“She said Mason was going to kill himself,” Richard told investigators. “She begged me to bring Natalie back so they could talk.”
He turned the car around.
Natalie protested.
Richard drove her back anyway.
That was the last time he saw her.
His cowardice had delivered her directly into danger.
But he claimed she was alive when he left.
Investigators now focused on Mason and Beatrice.
Search teams returned to the property.
Cadaver dogs examined the greenhouse and surrounding woods.
Nothing.
Then police discovered that one of the Whitmore rental properties had been renovated immediately after Natalie vanished.
A basement floor had been completely replaced.
The property became the next search site.
While investigators worked, Mason’s attorney attempted to contact me.
Dana refused.
Then Mason sent a message through his lawyer.
He wanted to make a deal.
Not with prosecutors.
With me.
“He says he can tell you what happened to your pregnancy,” Dana said.
My entire body went cold.
“In exchange for what?”
“You withdrawing cooperation on certain financial allegations.”
I laughed.
It was not amusement.
It was disbelief.
“He thinks I can be bought with the truth about my own baby?”
“He’s desperate.”
“Tell him no.”
Dana nodded.
Then I changed my mind.
“Actually, tell him I’ll listen.”
“Claire—”
“I didn’t say I’ll agree.”
The meeting occurred by secure video with attorneys present.
Mason appeared on-screen from detention.
For the first time since I had known him, he looked small.
No expensive watch.
No polished jacket.
No mother standing behind him.
“Claire,” he said.
I felt nothing.
“Talk.”
He swallowed.
“My mother gave you something during the pregnancy.”
The room went silent.
“What?”
“She said it would help you sleep.”
“What was it?”
“I don’t know.”
“You expect me to believe that?”
“I swear.”
“Did you know she was giving it to me?”
“Yes.”
“Did you ask what it was?”
“No.”
I stared at him.
“You knew your mother was secretly giving your pregnant wife medication, and you never asked why?”
He looked away.
That was answer enough.
“Did she cause my miscarriage?”
“I don’t know.”
“Why would she?”
Mason hesitated.
Then said, “Because you were planning to move.”
I remembered.
During my pregnancy, I had been offered a promotion.
The job would have required relocating to Charlotte.
Mason refused.
I had told him I might accept anyway.
Beatrice became furious.
Two weeks later, I lost the baby.
My grief transformed into rage.
“You let me blame myself.”
Mason started crying.
“I was scared of losing everything.”
“You mean losing control.”
“I loved you.”
“No.”
My voice remained surprisingly steady.
“You loved access to me.”
I ended the call.
Hours later, Detective Bell arrived.
His expression told me something had happened.
At the rental property, investigators had found human remains beneath the basement floor.
Dental records would be needed for confirmation.
But beside the remains was a bracelet.
Hannah Pierce recognized it immediately.
It belonged to Natalie.
Mason and Beatrice were now facing an investigation far beyond financial crimes and assault.
The story reached local news.
Then regional news.
Reporters gathered outside the hospital.
Dana arranged additional security.
I wanted no publicity.
But publicity came anyway.
ATLANTA FAMILY INVESTIGATED AFTER REMAINS FOUND IN RENTAL HOME.
Then something unexpected happened.
Women began calling police.
Former tenants.
Former employees.
Former girlfriends.
One woman claimed Beatrice had helped her husband hide assets during a divorce.
Another said Mason had pressured her into signing financial documents years earlier.
The Whitmore system was larger than anyone imagined.
And one call changed the investigation again.
A woman named Patricia Lane told police she had worked as Beatrice’s housekeeper for fourteen years.
She claimed she knew what happened the night Natalie disappeared.
But Patricia wanted protection before she spoke.
May you like
When Bell asked why, she answered:
“Because Natalie wasn’t the first woman Beatrice buried.”
